Sally Hansen: Hidden Treasure Vs Nail Pop: Sequin Effect

I  purchased Hidden Treasure via amazon for £2.66, absolute bargain!  you can find it here & I purchased a similar looking flaky polish from Superdrug  - Nail Pop: Sequin Effect  £5


Hidden Treasure arrived in the mail only 20 minutes ago and I had to try it out.  Below: Hidden Treasure  over China Glaze: Strawberry Fields.

Both Hidden Treasure & Sequin Effect  have  a beautiful green/orange  flaky shimmer, but the real magic happens over black.

This is one coat. Excuse the nubbin & mess (this is my evil left hand that causes my nails to break more often )

    Index & Ring Finger:  Hidden Treasure /  Middle Finger & Pinky:  Nail Pop 

So let's try it on the right which is easier on the eyes; Both look incredibly similar here, but Hidden Treasure has more of a red/orange flash.

       

 Index & Ring Finger  = Hidden Treasure /  Middle Finger & Pinky = Nail Pop 

Hidden Treasure is definitely  more of an orangy  red with flashes of green, but Nail Pop just seems to flash  green and only a hint of orange , and isn't as strong, so Hidden Treasure is the winner here for me.